Rentals

When it comes to renting at Creston House, owners have multiple options beside using Coastal. In addition to Airbnb and Vrbo, there are also some full service rental companies that already operate at Creston House.

Fairly

Fairly is a full-service vacation rental management company focused on maximizing owner revenue while providing exceptional guest experiences. Their team combines advanced revenue management technology with local market expertise to help owners increase occupancy, improve nightly rates, and reduce the day-to-day responsibilities of managing a vacation rental.

Fairly Provides:

Dynamic pricing optimization based on market demand
Distribution across Airbnb, VRBO, Expedia, Google Vacation Rentals, and direct booking channels
Guest communication and reservation management
Local caretaker support
Professional photography and listing optimization
Revenue management and performance monitoring
Owner portal with complete transparency
No long-term contracts

Saint Augustine Beach Market Insights from Fairly:

Strong demand for beachfront and near-beach properties
Peak occupancy during spring, summer, holidays, Nights of Lights, and special events
Increasing importance of dynamic pricing and professional marketing
Higher-performing properties benefiting from multi-channel exposure and active revenue management
Owners who actively manage pricing, visibility, and guest experience are often better positioned to maximize occupancy and annual rental income.

For interested Creston House owners, Fairly will provide the following:

A one-page overview specifically tailored for Creston House owners
Saint Augustine Beach occupancy and revenue trends
Comparable property performance data
Typical nightly rate ranges by season
Revenue management and pricing strategy information
Examples of how Fairly helps maximize visibility and bookings

For more information, contact Kendra at 904-842-3675 or via email at kendra.keller@fairly.com.

You may also contact Wes Keller, local advisor and caretaker partner, at 904-679-8912 or wesleykeller98@gmail.com for property-specific questions, local operations, and caretaker services.

First Choice Florida

First Choice Florida is a local, full-service property management company for the Saint Augustine and Crescent Beach area since 2013, built by a team with rental experience dating back to the late 1990s.

There is one local team with an office at 1017 A1A Beach Blvd (Publix Shopping Center), just a few minutes north of Creston House.

First Choice services include:

Owner portal with live booking calendar access.
Guest communication
Cleaning and maintenance handled in-house
Calls connect with Saint Augustine office, not a call center.
Multi-channel marketing: listings on Airbnb, Vrbo, Google Vacation Rentals, and company's own direct-booking site
Professional photography
Optimized listings
Season-aware dynamic pricing, informed by decades of local market experience

70+ homes and condos managed across Saint Augustine, Saint Augustine Beach, Butler Beach, and Crescent Beach

Creston House owners receive a free rental estimate. For more information call 904-429-7373, email stay@firstchoiceflorida.com, or visit 1017, A1A Beach Blvd.

Page last updated: 6/23/26